Some links in this guide are affiliate links — if you book through them, we get a small kickback. Helps us keep making these guides free. We only recommend places we'd actually send a friend to.
Five Days in NYC Isn't Enough. Here's the Honest Plan Anyway.
Five days in New York is not enough. Ten days isn't either. So the honest move is to pick a neighborhood, post up, and let yourself walk.
This guide is opinionated on purpose. There are 23,000 restaurants in this city; we're going to send you to ten. Some are famous, some are not, all are places we'd put a group of friends. We've also got the train math, the tipping rules, and the answer to "where should we actually stay" — because most NYC guides bury that question under a list of fifty hotels.
Assume you're a group of four or six. Assume mixed budgets. Assume someone wants the dinner that becomes a night, and someone else wants the cheap slice at 2am — and that the dinner-that-becomes-a-night will get split four ways, with one card and four reimbursements.
This is the guide for that trip.
Getting There and Around
Three airports serve New York. JFK is the biggest and furthest out — about 24km from Manhattan. The AirTrain into the city ($8.75) plus the subway gets you downtown in around 75 minutes for $11.65 total. A yellow cab is flat-rate $70 plus tolls and tip — call it $85.
LaGuardia is closer (14km) but smaller and has no rail link. The M60-SBS bus to Harlem is $3 and takes about 45 minutes; a taxi is $40–60 plus tolls.
Newark (EWR) is in New Jersey but well-connected. The AirTrain + NJ Transit train combo is $16 and takes about 45 minutes to Penn Station.
Once you're in town, the answer to almost every transportation question is the subway. It runs 24/7. The base fare in 2026 is $3.00, and you tap your phone, watch, or credit card at the turnstile — this is OMNY. After 12 rides in a 7-day window, the rest of the week is free.
Where to Stay: Pick a Neighborhood, Not a Hotel
The neighborhood matters more than the hotel. NYC is a city of small worlds.
Lower East Side / East Village is our default recommendation. Nine Orchard, a century-old bank turned hotel on Orchard Street, is the standout splurge here — rooms from $475 in shoulder season.
Williamsburg, Brooklyn is where Manhattan goes on the weekend. The Wythe Hotel is a 1901 factory turned hotel — exposed brick, big rooms, a rooftop bar.
Tribeca is the splurge option. Midtown we'd skip unless you're seeing Broadway. Budget? Try Now Now NoHo — rates from $125.
Food & Drink: Where We'd Actually Send You
Via Carota. 51 Grove Street, West Village. The kind of place where one plate becomes four, four become eight, and somehow it's 11pm and everyone wants to stay. Pasta runs $22–32. No reservations.
Joe's Pizza. 7 Carmine Street, since 1975. The slice is the slice. $4 a slice.
Carbone. Yes, it's the one you've seen on Instagram. The spicy rigatoni vodka is worth it. Reservations on Resy at 10am exactly 30 days out.
Russ & Daughters Cafe. 127 Orchard Street. Family-run since 1914.
Katz's Delicatessen. 205 E Houston Street. The pastrami is the point — on rye, with mustard, $28.
Moustache Pitza. 90 Bedford Street, open since the '80s. Order ten dips, none of them wrong.
Kabawa. Caribbean prix-fixe in the East Village. $150–200 per person.
Le Chêne. Newer Parisian arrival in the West Village.
Culture & Museums: How to See It Without Burning Out
Pick three. Don't try to do five.
The Met. $30 admission gets you in for three consecutive days. End with a drink at the Cantor Roof Garden.
MoMA. The Starry Night is here. Free for NY State residents Fridays 5:30–8:30pm.
The Whitney. Free for visitors 25 and under. Free Friday nights 5–10pm.
The Tenement Museum. Stand inside a real tenement apartment from 1869. Better than any documentary.
Saving money: Look at the CityPASS if you're hitting four or more big-ticket attractions.
Things to Do Beyond the Tourist Maps
Central Park. 843 acres of breath. Walk it without a plan.
The High Line. A 1.45-mile elevated park.
Governors Island. A $5 ferry ride and you're somewhere that feels nothing like the city.
Broadway. The TKTS booth sells day-of seats at half price.
SUMMIT One Vanderbilt. Tickets $43–78.
Beat the Bomb. Suit up in hazmat gear, crack codes, dodge foam cannons. Stupid in the best way.
Day Trips When the City Is Too Much
Cold Spring. 70 minutes on the Metro-North. Breakneck Ridge trailhead.
Dia Beacon. 90 minutes by Metro-North. One of the largest contemporary art museums in the world.
Long Beach, Long Island. 50 minutes on the LIRR. Closest real beach to Manhattan.
What This Trip Actually Costs
Budget — $90/day. Hostel or budget hotel, pizza slices and dumpling counters, subway, one paid attraction every other day.
Mid-range — $200/day. Mid-tier hotel, one nice dinner and one casual meal, subway, one paid attraction per day. This is most groups.
Splurge — $450+/day. Boutique hotel, dinner at Carbone or Kabawa, rideshares everywhere, Broadway and SUMMIT.
Practical Tips Nobody Tells You
Tipping
18–20% standard at sit-down restaurants. 20%+ at upscale spots. $1–2 per drink at bars.
When to come
April–May and September–October are the sweet spot. Avoid August and February.
Phone and data
eSIMs from Airalo or Holafly work the moment you land.
Safety
NYC is generally safe in tourist neighborhoods at most hours. Standard urban awareness.
Drilling into a specific angle?
If a category needs more depth, that is what the niche guides are for:
NYC Food Guide — 30 restaurants we would send a friend to.
NYC Museum Guide — pick three. Do not try to see five.
Things to Do in NYC — 23 plans beyond tourist traps.
NYC on a Budget — the whole trip for under $100 a day.
NYC in December — holiday markets, ice skating, NYE done right.
